If you had any doubt that US politics are run by a pay-to-play system, listen to the striking commentary made by Alabama US Rep. Mo Brooks in the video above. The leaked audio is from an event held in March 20221 and explains, in no uncertain terms, that seats on the most powerful committees in Congress must be bought, at a price of $ 1 million or more.
The money for these seats doesn’t come from average Americans, who typically can’t afford to donate that much. It comes from lobbyists, who offer to pay the price of the seat in exchange for political favors. “Special interest groups run Washington, and I don’t mean that metaphorically,” Brooks said. “I mean literally.”2
The Truth About Corruption in DC
Brooks, who is running for the Senate, said to event attendees, “I’m sure that you are very much concerned about why our Congress is so unresponsive to the regular needs of American citizens, why some of these policies that come out are so bizarre , so unfair, so skewered against regular Jane and Joe Citizen. ”3 The reason is simple, he continued – it’s because of the entrenched corruption. He continued:4
“Now here is how it happens. In the House of Representatives – I use that as an example because that’s where I work – if you want to be chairman of a major committee, you have to purchase it. And the purchase price for a major committee, say like Ways and Means, the minimum bid is a million dollars. And I’m talking literally here. I’m not talking metaphorically, OK? ”
He then goes on to explain that the committees are actually broken down into categories depending on their different price points:5
“We have broken committees by A group, B group and C group. C are the cheapest, B are… middling, A is the most expensive. It’s the most expensive because those are the committees that the special interest groups care the most about. ”
In the US House of Representatives, committees play an important role. They consider bills and issues as well as oversee agencies, programs and activities that fall within their jurisdictions.6 The only congresspersons who can afford seats on the most expensive committees, however, are typically those who take lobbyists’ money to do so:7
“So where does a congressman come up with $ 1 million to be chairman of one of these eight committees? You can’t get it from Joe and Jane Citizen because Joe and Jane Citizen back home, they’re not going to be contributing that kind of money. They don’t have it. They need that money for their own families… And so you have to get it from the special interest groups. ”
Politicians Depend on Money From Lobbyists in Quid Pro Quo
Money from special interest groups comes with strings attached, and the groups give it out strategically to gain leverage on politicians who will further their own agendas.8 According to Brooks:9
“With the special interest groups, there is a quid pro quo. If you don’t do what they tell you to do, they won’t give you the money that finances your chairmanship. I had one guy who ran for the chairman of the NRCC, which is where the Republicans pay their money for these committee assignments and chairmanships, just as the Democrats pay theirs to the DCCC.
And this guy who wanted to be the chair of the NRCC actually had a brochure and that brochure had price listings written on it. And his argument for getting elected was, ‘Elect me. I will charge you less. ‘”
This arrangement, however, corrupts debate on public policy. “We need to be in a position of power,” Brooks said. “You have to do what the special interest groups require, which undermines the public policy debate.
The money now is a triumph. ”10 He then gave the example of Rep. Thomas Massie, who was approached by a lobbyist from the medical device sector who offered to pay $ 500,000 so Massie could be on the Ways and Means Committee, which oversees tax policy – but only if he would sponsor a patent bill.
The Ways and Means Committee, by the way, is one of the most powerful and sought-after committees. To give you an idea of how coveted a seat on this committee is, Open Secrets explained:11
“When Congress is drafting tax legislation, there is no committee busier and more popular than House Ways and Means. Lobbyists often pay people to stand in the corridors of Congress watching committee members’ every move. Because when it comes to this type of complex legislation, every detail counts for something.
Special interests often use these behemoth bills as vehicles for their legislative wish lists, hoping the sheer size of the proposals will divert attention from their sought-after provisions. Since tax bills affect so many industries’ bottom lines, it’s little surprise that members should attract generous donations from a variety of sources, including health professionals and insurance companies. ”
“Thomas is a diamond. He has patents, he’s an MIT grad, ”Brooks said, so Massie agreed to look at the patent, which turned out to be harmful to small inventors. “The people with the power and the money are going to use that power and money to steal the patent rights from the person who actually had the idea, who should be reaping the rewards of that idea,” Brooks said.12
Massie told the lobbyist he wouldn’t sponsor the patent, so the lobbyist took back his offer to pay the $ 500,000. This story was published by USA Today in 2016, meaning it’s no secret that such exchanges occur. At the time, Massie told USA Today:13
“It was one of the scummiest meetings I’ve ever been in. I left just reeling, thinking about the implications for how this place works, when you realize that the lobbyists pick who goes on which committee. ”
There was only one thing that Massie wished he’d said differently to the press, Brooks said. He’d talked about lobbyists buying committee assignments, but really, he told Brooks, “It’s a rental agreement. You have to pay it every two years. ”14
Most Politicians Are Working for Their Own Self-Interest
What’s clear is that systemic corruption is present, with most politicians not fighting for the public but, rather, looking out for their own self-interest and wealth accumulation. Many political campaigns run on the platform that they’re just like the average American, but personal financial disclosures reveal that more than half of Congress members are millionaires, with a median net worth of just over $ 1 million.15
Further, the top 10% of the lawmakers in terms of wealth are three times richer than the bottom 90%.16 Many of them become multimillionaires by trading stocks and options. Are their successful trades just luck or do they benefit from their inside knowledge about the corporations they trade – and their power to wield legislation that affects the companies ’futures?
Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi, for instance, earns $ 223,500 a year, making her the third-highest-paid elected official in the US17 Yet, since 2004, her wealth has increased from $ 41 million to nearly $ 115 million, according to OpenSecrets, which began tracking lawmakers’ personal finances that year.18
In the last two years, nearly 75% of Pelosi’s stock trades have involved Big Tech stocks, totaling over $ 33 million in trading. “That has happened as major legislation is pending before the House, controlled by the committees Pelosi oversees, which could radically reshape the industry and laws that govern the very companies in which she and her husband most aggressively trade,” Pulitzer Prize winning journalist Glenn Greenwald wrote.19
Greenwald also revealed that Pelosi’s five most-traded stocks in the last two years – Apple, Microsoft, Facebook, Amazon and Google – were those that stood to be most affected by pending legislation. And, not just any legislation, but legislation that she was working to negotiate and work through Congress.
Another example is Sen. Kelly Loeffler, R-Ga., Who has an estimated worth of over $ 500 million.20 She and her husband, New York Stock Exchange chief executive Jeff Sprecher, came under fire for suspicious stock trades worth between $ 1.2 million and $ 3.1 million that occurred immediately after a “closed-door coronavirus briefing in late January” 2020.21 Among them:22
- Buying stock in an online travel booking site in February 2020, then selling it four days later, just before a ban on flights from Europe was publicly announced
- Purchasing stock in Citrix, which sells GoToMeeting teleworking software
Sen. Richard Burr, chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee, who receives frequent briefings about potential US threats, also dumped stock, including in hotel companies, worth up to $ 1.7 million in late January 2020.23 Sen. Dianne Feinstein from California and Sen. James Inhofe of Oklahoma also sold stock after Intelligence Committee briefings.24
Revolving Door: Politicians Often Become Lobbyists
Another issue is the revolving door between politicians, who are supposed to be performing a public service, and the private sector. After their political careers end, many go on to serve as lobbyists or work in the corporate world, which means that during their tenure, they want to keep doors open that may help them once they’re no longer in politics. As noted by Open Secrets:25
“When American voters discard elected officials – and their staffs – lobbying firms and interest groups are quick to snap up the unemployed. Lobbying firms – which often charge steep fees from their deep-pocketed clients – can offer former government employees salaries far greater than those proffered by Uncle Sam, as well as continued influence on Capitol Hill.
In return, firms get lobbyists who already have established connections in the federal government and whose résumés can act as a powerful draw for potential clients. ”
In regard to former members of the 115th Congress alone, out of 106 members, 62 found new employment – nearly half of them with lobbying firms:26
“Lawmakers who exited their congressional offices in January 2019 landed in a variety of careers – but as usual, a good share of them spun through the revolving door to lobbying shops. While they technically couldn’t lobby their former colleagues immediately (though the same wasn’t true of the executive branch), they could keep themselves busy during their cooling-off periods by advising clients and bearing titles like ‘strategic adviser.’ “
The Corruption Runs Deep
Regarding the pay-to-play corruption exposed by Brooks and Massie, while the national media are aware of the issue, and both political parties are guilty of engaging in it, no one is bringing it to the forefront as a major public policy issue.27 Yet, the corruption runs so deep that, in the “Breaking Points” video above, it’s pointed out that even Brooks and Massie aren’t immune.
While Brooks has received money from real estate interests and developers, and the military-industrial complex industry, Massie has personally invited lobbyists to fundraising events. “He’s playing the game himself here,” says host Krystal Ball, referring to Brooks. “He’s exposing the game in this regard, but in no way are his hands clean… They love to posture, but then they’re just as guilty of playing the same game as everybody else.”28